Options-based income funds have grown into a major category, and covered call funds get most of the attention. But there’s a close relative that’s less well known and sometimes a better fit: funds that sell put options. Both strategies collect premiums by selling options on stocks or stock indexes. Both produce high income and give up some upside in exchange. And on paper, they can produce very similar results. In practice, they behave differently in ways that matter for investors trying to pick between them.
Start with the mechanics.
A covered call fund owns a portfolio of stocks or an index and sells call options on it. A call option gives the buyer the right to buy the stock at a set price, the strike price, before a certain date. The fund collects a premium for selling that right. If the stock stays below the strike, the option expires worthless and the fund keeps the premium. If the stock rises above the strike, the fund’s gains are capped, because the shares will effectively be called away at the strike price.
A put-writing fund doesn’t own stocks at all, at least not at first. Instead, it holds cash, usually in Treasury bills, and sells put options on a stock or index. A put option gives the buyer the right to sell the stock at the strike price. The fund collects a premium for agreeing to buy at that price. If the stock stays above the strike, the option expires worthless and the fund keeps the premium. If the stock falls below the strike, the fund takes the loss, effectively buying the stock at a price above where it’s trading.
Here’s the part that surprises many investors. A covered call position and a cash-secured put position at the same strike price have nearly the same risk and payoff profile. This relationship, known as put-call parity, means that owning a stock and selling a call on it is economically similar to holding cash and selling a put. Both strategies make money in flat or modestly rising markets, both give up gains in strong rallies, and both take losses in falling markets, cushioned only by the premium.
The long-term records support that. Cboe publishes benchmark indexes for both strategies on the S&P 500. Over long periods, the put-write index and the buy-write index have produced broadly similar returns, both with less volatility than the S&P 500 itself and both lagging it in strong bull markets.
So why does the choice matter? Because the details of how funds implement each strategy create real differences.
The first is the role of interest rates. A put-writing fund’s collateral sits in Treasury bills, and that collateral earns interest. With bills paying close to 4%, a large share of a put-writing fund’s return comes from the T-bill yield alone, before any option premium. A covered call fund’s return comes from stock dividends and option premiums instead. When short-term rates are high, the put-writing structure looks more attractive. When rates were near zero, the collateral earned almost nothing and the strategy depended entirely on premiums.
The second is taxes. Covered call funds hold stocks, which pay qualified dividends taxed at lower rates. Put-writing funds earn interest on Treasuries, which is taxed as ordinary income but is exempt from state tax. Index options on broad indexes like the S&P 500 typically qualify for special tax treatment under Section 1256, with gains and losses taxed as 60% long-term and 40% short-term regardless of how long they’re held. The overall tax picture depends on the fund’s structure and the investor’s bracket, and it’s worth reading the fund’s tax history before buying.
The third is how the fund handles losses. A put-writing fund that sells puts on an index settles in cash. If the market falls, the fund pays the difference and keeps its collateral reduced. It doesn’t actually end up owning stocks. A covered call fund owns stocks the whole time, so it participates in any rebound right away. After a sharp drop, this can make the covered call fund recover faster, depending on how the put-writing fund resets its strikes.
The fourth is distribution style. Many covered call funds, especially the newer high-yield ETFs, pay large monthly distributions that can include return of capital. Put-writing funds tend to be less marketed for income and more for total return, though some do pay monthly.
The fifth is volatility. Both strategies earn more when volatility is high, because options become more expensive. The VIX was elevated through parts of this year as AI stocks sold off and oil swung, then dropped to around 18.5 after the midterm elections. Lower volatility means smaller premiums for both strategies.
How should investors choose?
Investors who want to keep owning stocks, collect dividends and have some income layered on top may prefer covered call funds. They’re more intuitive for many people and fit well alongside a traditional equity allocation.
Investors who want a lower-volatility equity-like return with a base of Treasury income may prefer put-writing funds, especially while short-term rates are high. Some advisors use put-writing funds as a partial substitute for both stocks and bonds, since the strategy has elements of each.
Either way, the biggest risk is the same. Neither strategy protects against a sharp market decline. Both will fall in a bear market, cushioned only by premiums and, for put-writers, by T-bill interest. And both will lag badly in a strong rally. These are strategies for steady markets and for investors who are willing to give up big gains for steadier returns.